Horse Profile / NZRacing

Performance
Breeding

Race info

Flat Rating: 99
Steeple Rating: 0
Hurdle Rating: 0

Current Gear:
- Approved Plates
- Blinkers
- Lugging Bit

Horse Details

18 (ret) Bay Gelding

Owner: A P Ritchie, B A Bellingham & S E Anderson
Breeder: Windsor Park Stud Ltd

Sire: VOLKSRAAD (GB) 1988
Dam: ALL NIGHT PARTY (NZ) 1993
Foaling: 7 Oct 2006

Current Nominations

Current Fields

Performance stats

Form

6104X

1st up

15-2-3

2nd up

3-1-2

Fresh 30

11-1-2

Fresh 90

4-1-1

Sectionals

Career stats

Click checkbox to show these races only. You can click on multiple checkboxes at once.

In-depth racing review

Overseas starts last updated on 18 Jul 2014

4-16

5 Jul 14

3200m Listed Race

QLD CUP

$163,455

E FM Good

QLD CUP

, 3.21.26

D Browne

$6,538

3.21.26, Flat
5.4L
Bar: 9
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 58.0
Car: 58.0
LWD: 54.0

1: Iggi Pop (NZ), 54.0
2: Pop 'n' Scotch, 54.0
3½ len:1½ len

Raceday Gear:

11-12

21 Jun 14

2200m Group 3

TATT'S CUP

$223,389

E FM Soft

TATT'S CUP

, 2.17.73

R M McMahon

2.17.73, Flat
4.1L
Bar: 10
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 58.0
Car: 58.0
LWD: 54.0

1: The Inventor, 54.0
2: Wish Come True (IRE), 55.5
lng hd:1 Len

Raceday Gear:

1-10

1 Jun 14

2150m

TOOWOOMBA CUP

$108,970

TWBA Soft

TOOWOOMBA CUP

, 2.16.33

R M McMahon

$69,741

2.16.33, Flat
.0L
Bar: 1
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 59.5
Car: 59.5
LWD: 59.5

2: Carn, 54.0
3: Extreme Mover, 54.0
lng nk:lng nk

Raceday Gear:

6-14

24 May 14

2200m Group 3

PREMIER'S CUP

$137,411

DOOM Good

PREMIER'S CUP

, 2.13.37

R M McMahon

2.13.37, Flat
7.6L
Bar: 8
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 56.5
Car: 56.5
LWD: 54.0

1: Zephyron (NZ), 54.0
2: Precedence (NZ), 59.5
¾ len:1 Len

Raceday Gear:

9-11

3 May 14

1800m Group 2

HOLLINDALE STKS

$391,638

GCST Heavy

HOLLINDALE STKS

, 1.53.17

R M McMahon

1.53.17, Flat
14.5L
Bar: 5
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 59.0
Car: 59.0
LWD: 59.0

1: Streama, 57.0
2: Mr O'ceirin (NZ), 59.0
½ len:½ len

Raceday Gear:

2-13	29 Mar 14	2000m Group 2	EZIBUY AWAPUNI GOLD CUP		$100,000
MTU Good4		OPN-SW&P	10th otr,impr 600,led 200,fght hard	Leith Innes	$19,000
2.05.06, Flat .4L Bar: 4 SP: $10.40 Rtg: 100 (-1) Wgt: 56.0 Car: 56.0 LWD: 53.0 1: Soriano, 53.5 3: Nashville, 59.0 LONG NECK:3/4 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit Stipe Comment: Bumped 400m becoming unbalanced, lay in shortly after.

9-16	15 Feb 14	2400m Group 2	GO RACING SYNDICATIONS AVONDALE CUP		$100,000
AUCK Good3		OPN HCP	14th outrwdr tn,plugged	Jonathan Riddell	$1,000
2.29.18, Flat 8.2L Bar: 9 SP: $28.30 Rtg: 101 (-1) Wgt: 59.0 Car: 59.0 LWD: 52.0 1: Who Shot Thebarman, 53.5 2: Skysoblue, 55.0 2 1/2 LEN:3/4 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit Stipe Comment: began awkwardly losing ground

11-15	25 Jan 14	2400m Group 2	PLATINUM HOMES WELLINGTON CUP (GROUP II)		$200,000
WELL Good3		OPN HCP	12th otr,bk otr 500,no danger	Jonathan Riddell	$0
2.29.30, Flat 5.5L Bar: 12 SP: $13.30 Rtg: 102 (-1) Wgt: 59.0 Car: 59.0 LWD: 52.0 1: Graphic, 52.0 2: Skysoblue, 53.0 1 LEN:LONG NECK Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

3-4	14 Jan 14	1150m	OPN Catchweight 1150 - Heat 17		$0
WAPA Firm2		OPN HCP		Ming Cheung	$0
1.10.96, Flat Bar: 4 SP: $0.00 Rtg: 102 Wgt: 0.0 Car: 0.0 LWD: 0.0 1: Packing Tycoon (IRE), 0.0 2: Juggernaut Rock (AUS), 0.0 1 1/4 LEN:3 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

1-11	21 Dec 13	2300m Group 3	HOTEL COACHMAN MANAWATU CUP		$70,000
MTU Good4		OPN HCP	3bk inr,wdr,loomed 200,too strong, 2.21.23	Jonathan Riddell	$40,625
2.21.23, Flat .2L Bar: 4 SP: $4.90 Rtg: 99 (+3) Wgt: 58.0 Car: 58.0 LWD: 53.0 2: Who Shot Thebarman, 53.0 3: Santos, 55.0 LONG HEAD:1 1/2 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

2-7	10 Dec 13	1200m	OPN HCP Catchweight 1200 - Heat 23		$0
CAMB Soft5		OPN HCP		Ming Cheung	$0
1.12.19, Flat Bar: 2 SP: $0.00 Rtg: 99 Wgt: 0.0 Car: 0.0 LWD: 0.0 1: Sequin, 0.0 3: Alessandra, 0.0 1/2 LEN:2 1/4 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

1-8	12 Nov 13	2100m	ECOLAB HANDICAP		$25,000
MTU Good3		OPN HCP	6th outr to tn, out 300,pouncd 150m, 2.09.59	Jonathan Riddell	$15,625
2.09.59, Flat 1.3L Bar: 7 SP: $14.20 Rtg: 96 (+3) Wgt: 59.0 Car: 59.0 LWD: 54.0 2: Figure Again, 54.0 3: Wisecrack, 54.0 1 1/4 LEN:LONG NECK Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

9-13	26 Oct 13	1400m	HAROLD PLUMLEY 1400		$25,000
AUCK Good3		OPN HCP	12th otr,wdr tn,beat tired ones	Jason Jago	$250
1.23.28, Flat 5.4L Bar: 2 SP: $41.50 Rtg: 97 (-1) Wgt: 58.0 Car: 58.0 LWD: 54.0 1: Shuka, 61.0 2: Spin Doctor, 55.5 LONG NECK:1 1/2 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit Stipe Comment: Crowded 1300m then steadied.

U-10	8 Oct 13	1200m	OPN HCP Catchweight 1200 - Heat 26		$0
CAMB Soft5		OPN HCP		Jason Jago	$0
1.13.24, Flat Bar: 4 SP: $0.00 Rtg: 97 Wgt: 0.0 Car: 0.0 LWD: 0.0 1: Stanica Star, 0.0 1: Princess Kyoto, 0.0 DEAD HEAT:SHORT NECK Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

U-10	24 Sep 13	1200m	OPN Catchweight 1200 - Heat 3		$0
EBOP Heavy8		OPN HCP		Jason Jago	$0
1.14.39, Flat Bar: 7 SP: $0.00 Rtg: 97 Wgt: 0.0 Car: 0.0 LWD: 0.0 1: My Scotsgrey, 0.0 2: Artemis, 0.0 1/2 HEAD:3/4 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

10-11	6 Apr 13	1400m Premier Meeting	TEAM WEALLEANS 1400		$40,000
TROA Soft6		OPN HCP	3bk inr,wdr und rd 500,no dash	Jason Jago	$0
1.26.44, Flat 10.1L Bar: 7 SP: $14.40 Rtg: 98 (-1) Wgt: 57.5 Car: 57.5 LWD: 53.0 1: Maximum Height, 55.5 2: Made My Point, 54.0 1/2 LEN:1 1/4 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

1-6	26 Mar 13	1150m	OPN HCP Catchweight 1150 - Heat 17		$0
PAER Good3		OPN HCP	, 1.09.39	Jason Jago	$0
1.09.39, Flat Bar: 4 SP: $0.00 Rtg: 98 Wgt: 0.0 Car: 0.0 LWD: 0.0 2: John Gray, 0.0 3: Colombian Praise, 0.0 HEAD:1 1/2 LEN Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

2-9	12 Mar 13	1200m	OPN HCP Catchweight 1200 - Heat 23		$0
CAMB Good3		OPN HCP		Jason Jago	$0
1.12.33, Flat Bar: 3 SP: $0.00 Rtg: 98 Wgt: 0.0 Car: 0.0 LWD: 0.0 1: Beyond All Doubt, 0.0 3: No Nonsense, 0.0 LONG NECK:1/2 HEAD Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

14-14

15 Jul 12

1600m

The Sha Tin Mile Trophy (Handicap)

$281,931

SHTN Good

Class 1

, 1.37.47

J McDonald

1.35.10, Flat
14.8L
Bar: 2
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 59.4
Car: 59.4
LWD: 59.4

1: Dan Excel, 54.8
2: Familists, 60.3
Short Head:Nose

Raceday Gear:

9-12

4 Jul 12

1200m

HING MAN HANDICAP

$265,000

HYVY Firm

Class 1

, 1.10.19

WM Lai

1.09.84, Flat
2.3L
Bar: 5
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 58.9
Car: 58.9
LWD: 55.3

1: Arrived Ahead, 57.6
2: Horse Galore, 55.7
3/4 LEN:3/4 LEN

Raceday Gear:

10-12

6 Jun 12

1800m

The Happy Valley Vase (Handicap)

$281,931

HYVY Good

Class 1

, 1.49.98

O Doleuze

1.48.98, Flat
6.3L
Bar: 11
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 54.8
Car: 54.8
LWD: 54.8

1: Happy Guys, 51.2
2: Pure Champion, 60.3
Head:Neck

Raceday Gear:

6-12

16 May 12

1200m

Venus Handicap

$281,931

SHTN Soft

Class 1

, 1.09.68

KC Leung

1.09.22, Flat
2.8L
Bar: 3
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 59.4
Car: 59.4
LWD: 59.4

1: Flying Colours, 56.2
2: Cerise Cherry, 56.6
Nose:Neck

Raceday Gear:

11-12

18 Mar 12

1800m Group 3

THE PREMIER PLATE

$356,502

SHTN Good

, 1.49.69

K Fallon

1.47.43, Flat
14.0L
Bar: 3
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 54.4
Car: 54.4
LWD: 54.4

1: Thumbs Up, 60.3
2: King of Scots, 51.2
1 1/2 LEN:1/2 LEN

Raceday Gear:

8-12

11 Jan 12

1800m Group 3

THE JANUARY CUP

$356,502

HYVY Good

, 1.49.63

N Callan

1.48.61, Flat
6.5L
Bar: 4
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 55.3
Car: 55.3
LWD: 54.4

1: Pure Champion, 54.4
2: Packing OK, 51.7
1/2 LEN:3 3/4 LEN

Raceday Gear:

1-14

4 Dec 11

1650m

The Peninsula Jubilee Challenge Cup (Handicap)

$219,279

SHTN Firm

Class 1

, 1.39.32

N Callan

$137,049

1.39.32, Flat
1.7L
Bar: 11
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 60.3
Car: 60.3
LWD: 60.3

2: Helene Spirit, 54.8
3: Flashing Aura, 53.0
1 3/4L:Nose

Raceday Gear:

2-14

5 Nov 11

1650m

Broadwood Handicap

$219,279

SHTN Good

Class 1

, 1.39.44

T Clark

$43,855

1.39.24, Flat
1.3L
Bar: 1
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 60.3
Car: 60.3
LWD: 60.3

1: King of Reason, 50.3
3: Just Fantastic, 59.8
1 1/4L:2 1/4L

Raceday Gear:

6-12

23 Oct 11

1650m

Admiralty Handicap

$219,279

HYVY Good

Class 1

, 1.40.49

D Beadman

1.40.49, Flat
.3L
Bar: 3
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 59.8
Car: 59.8
LWD: 59.8

1: Outdoor Pegasus, 56.6
2: Happy Tumbler, 54.8
Nose:1 3/4L

Raceday Gear:

1-14

9 Oct 11

1650m

Egret Handicap

$219,279

SHTN Good

Class 1

, 1.39.11

D Beadman

$137,049

1.39.11, Flat
1.0L
Bar: 9
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 56.2
Car: 56.2
LWD: 56.2

2: Fortune Red Pepper, 56.6
3: Mighty Sun, 56.6
1L:Neck

Raceday Gear:

6-14

25 Sep 11

1400m

Cumberland Handicap

$187,954

SHTN Good

Class 2

, 1.22.84

D Beadman

1.22.41, Flat
2.8L
Bar: 6
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 58.0
Car: 58.0
LWD: 52.2

1: Voile Rouge, 56.6
2: Penglai Xianzi, 56.2
Nose:1L

Raceday Gear:

4-14

10 Jul 11

1400m

THE HONG KONG RACEHORSE OWNERS ASSOCIATION

$171,827

SHTN Good

Class 2

, 1.22.55

D Beadman

$9,006

1.21.94, Flat
3.8L
Bar: 5
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 60.3
Car: 60.3
LWD: 53.0

1: Sweet Orange, 53.0
2: Adoration, 55.7
2 1/4 LEN:LEN

Raceday Gear:

10-11

1 May 11

1600m

AUDEMARS PIGUET LADY MILLENARY HANDICAP

$207,959

SHTN Good

Class 1

, 1.36.30

D Beadman

1.35.47, Flat
5.3L
Bar: 10
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 57.6
Car: 57.6
LWD: 51.7

1: Fat Choy Oohlala, 56.2
2: Hot Shot, 52.6
1 3/4 LEN:NECK

Raceday Gear:

4-14

9 Apr 11

1600m

CHOW TAI FOOK IN GOLD COLLECTION HANDICAP

$170,824

SHTN Good

Class 2

, 1.34.80

D Beadman

$9,006

1.34.59, Flat
1.3L
Bar: 14
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 60.3
Car: 60.3
LWD: 54.4

1: Destined For Glory, 58.5
2: Fat Choy Oohlala, 58.0
1/2 LEN:3/4 LEN

Raceday Gear:

6-14

20 Mar 11

2000m Group 1

THE MERCEDES-BENZ HONG KONG DERBY 2011

$2,527,104

SHTN

, 2.02.53

D Oliver

2.01.50, Flat
6.5L
Bar: 5
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 57.2
Car: 57.2
LWD: 57.2

1: AMBITIOUS DRAGON, 57.2
2: XTENSION, 57.2
3/4L:4 1/2L

Raceday Gear:

5-11

6 Mar 11

1800m

AMBER HANDICAP

$221,122

SHTN

Class 1

, 1.48.74

D Beadman

$5,280

1.48.48, Flat
1.8L
Bar: 7
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 59.0
Car: 59.0
LWD: 59.0

1: SAPELLI, 57.2
2: VICTOR DELIGHT, 54.9
Short Head:3/4L

Raceday Gear:

9-12

23 Jan 11

1600m Group 1

THE MERCEDES-BENZ HONG KONG CLASSIC MILE

$947,664

SHTN

, 1.35.05

N Callan

1.34.25, Flat
5.0L
Bar: 5
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 57.2
Car: 57.2
LWD: 57.2

1: LUCKY NINE, 57.2
2: XTENSION, 57.2
1 1/4L:2 1/2L

Raceday Gear:

2-14

19 Jan 11

1400m

HAIER HANDICAP

$181,636

HYVY

Class 2

, 1.22.80

D Beadman

$36,327

1.22.75, Flat
.1L
Bar: 11
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 59.9
Car: 59.9
LWD: 59.9

1: PAGANINI'S SOUL, 54.0
3: DANZULU, 55.3
Nose:3/4L

Raceday Gear:

3-14

19 Dec 10

1400m

THE MIDLAND HOLDINGS CUP

$181,636

SHTN

Class 2

, 1.22.60

J Lloyd

$27,245

1.22.40, Flat
1.3L
Bar: 5
SP: $0.00
Rtg:
Wgt: 59.4
Car: 59.4
LWD: 59.4

1: DRAGON FIGHTER, 52.2
2: DIEGO, 54.9
3/4L:1 1/4L

Raceday Gear:

1-15

6 Mar 10

2400m Group 1

TELECOM NZ DERBY

$2,200,000

AUCK Good3

3YO SW

Cosy trl,out tn,led 250,too strong, 2.27.91, 600m - 0.35.95

Michael Walker

$1,300,000

2.27.91, Flat
1.0L
Bar: 4
SP: $15.80
Rtg: 80 (+18)
Wgt: 56.0
Car: 56.0
LWD: 54.5

2: Corporal Jones, 56.0
3: Handsome Zulu, 56.0
LEN:NOSE

Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

5-15

20 Feb 10

2100m Group 2

NZ EQUINE VETERINARIANS CHAMPIONSHIP STAKES

$85,000

AUCK Firm2

3YO SW

Wd,easd 12th outr,wdr 300,solid fin

Noel Harris

$2,125

2.08.35, Flat
4.5L
Bar: 12
SP: $19.40
Rtg: 84 (-4)
Wgt: 56.0
Car: 56.0
LWD: 54.5

1: Zarzuela, 54.5
2: Corporal Jones, 56.0
HEAD:2 3/4 LEN

Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

4-13

6 Feb 10

2000m Group 3

HS DYKE WAIKATO GUINEAS (GROUP III)

$70,000

WAIK Firm2

3YO SW

Wd,up 2nd 1400,led tn,hdd 150,btld

Mark Du Plessis

$3,500

2.01.00, Flat
2.9L
Bar: 9
SP: $5.60
Rtg: 84
Wgt: 56.0
Car: 56.0
LWD: 54.5

1: Zarzuela, 54.5
2: Corporal Jones, 56.0
3/4 LEN:2 LEN

Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

Stipe Comment: Raced wide rounding first turn.

5-11

23 Jan 10

1600m Group 3

GRANT PLUMBING WELLINGTON STAKES

$70,000

WELL Soft6

3YO SW

3rd outr,chal 300,btld 100m

Mark Du Plessis

$1,625

1.36.72, Flat
1.6L
Bar: 2
SP: $5.50
Rtg: 84
Wgt: 56.0
Car: 56.0
LWD: 54.5

1: Joey Massino, 56.0
2: Handsome Zulu, 56.0
NOSE:1/2 HEAD

Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

2-15

7 Nov 09

1600m Group 1

NEW ZEALAND 2000 GUINEAS

$1,000,000

CANT Good3

3YO SW

Wrkd to ld,kikd clr 300,worn down

Mark Du Plessis

$175,000

1.34.91, Flat
1.0L
Bar: 13
SP: $11.00
Rtg: 75 (+9)
Wgt: 56.0
Car: 56.0
LWD: 54.5

1: Katie Lee (AUS), 54.5
3: Clapton, 56.0
LEN:NECK

Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit, Blinkers (1st time)

3-8

24 Oct 09

1500m Group 2

NEW ZEALAND BLOODSTOCK WELLINGTON THOROUGHBRED BREEDERS GUINEAS

$85,000

WELL Heavy10

3YO SW

Stld 1x1,out 300, btld on well

Jason Waddell

$8,000

1.36.19, Flat
5.3L
Bar: 3
SP: $6.10
Rtg: 74 (+1)
Wgt: 56.0
Car: 56.0
LWD: 54.5

1: Keyora, 56.0
2: Descarado, 56.0
1 1/4 LEN:4 LEN

Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

2-11

26 Sep 09

1400m Listed Race

GEON BONECRUSHER STAKES

$45,500

AUCK Soft7

3YO SW

8th 3w cvr,loomd 300,green,solid

Jason Waddell

$8,775

1.28.39, Flat
1.3L
Bar: 8
SP: $9.40
Rtg: 68 (+6)
Wgt: 56.0
Car: 56.0
LWD: 54.5

1: Jungle Juice, 54.5
3: Warrentherooster, 56.0
1 1/4 LEN:1 3/4 LEN

Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

Stipe Comment: ducked outwards when struck with whip 300m

1-12

9 Sep 09

1200m

McKAY RACING STABLES 3YO

$6,000

TAUP Good3

MDN 3YO

1x1, out tn, chal 200, drew out, 1.12.96

Jason Waddell

$3,750

1.12.96, Flat
1.0L
Bar: 3
SP: $4.80
Rtg: 50 (+18)
Wgt: 57.0
Car: 57.0
LWD: 55.5

2: Gendarme, 57.0
3: Vincitore, 55.5
LEN:4 1/4 LEN

Raceday Gear: Approved Plates, Lugging Bit

2-7

25 Aug 09

1150m

MDN 3YO Catchweight 1150 - Heat 24

WAPA Heavy10

MDN 3YO

Jason Waddell

1.16.87, Flat
Bar: 2
SP: $0.00
Rtg: 50
Wgt: 0.0
Car: 0.0
LWD: 0.0

1: Chief Secretary, 0.0
3: Isabella Soraya, 0.0
NECK:1/2 LEN

Raceday Gear:

1-7

11 Aug 09

950m

MDN 3YO Catchweight 950 - Heat 17

CAMB Heavy10

MDN 3YO

, 0.59.41

James McDonald

0.59.41, Flat
Bar: 5
SP: $0.00
Rtg: 50
Wgt: 0.0
Car: 0.0
LWD: 0.0

2: Green Cash, 0.0
3: Readallaboutit, 0.0
1/2 LEN:5 1/2 LEN

Raceday Gear:

2-9

16 Mar 09

1050m

2YO Catchweight 1050 - Heat 12

AVON Firm1

2YO

Samantha Collett

1.01.66, Flat
Bar: 8
SP: $0.00
Rtg: 50
Wgt: 0.0
Car: 0.0
LWD: 0.0

1: Kilkenny, 0.0
3: Zara Dancer, 0.0
NECK:6 LEN

Raceday Gear:

2-7

24 Feb 09

800m

2YO Catchweight 800 - Heat 6

AVON Good4

2YO

Samantha Collett

0.46.34, Flat
Bar: 7
SP: $0.00
Rtg: 50
Wgt: 0.0
Car: 0.0
LWD: 0.0

1: Tafari (AUS), 0.0
3: Carolina Gem, 0.0
1/4 LEN:5 LEN

Raceday Gear:

View Military Move (NZ) 2006's full breeding profile ›

Military Move (NZ) 2006

Trainer: - / -

Training Location: Cambridge

Race info

Horse Details

18 (ret) Bay Gelding

Current Nominations

Current Fields

Performance stats

Sectionals

Career stats

In-depth racing review